- ENGINEER COMPETENCY
A failed PUWER inspection is uncomfortable — but it is a controlled, well-defined situation if you handle it properly. The wrong response is panic or denial. The right one is a clear, documented process that takes the equipment out of service, fixes the underlying issue, and gets the operation back online without compounding the problem. This article walks through the steps.
A PUWER inspection report will normally categorise findings. Most competent persons use:
Only “immediate” defects mean the equipment cannot be used. Lower-severity findings still have time to be addressed — but they are binding, not optional.
For immediate-defect failures, isolate the equipment the moment the report is shared. Lock-off where electrical or pneumatic isolation is possible. Tag the equipment as out of service with the date, reason and the name of the person responsible.
Tell operators, supervisors and anyone scheduled to use the equipment. Update production planning so the work is rerouted. A failed inspection that operators are unaware of becomes an incident waiting to happen.
Ask why it failed. Look at:
The investigation feeds your corrective action. Without it, you fix the symptom and the next inspection finds the same problem.
Repairs must be carried out by a competent person, using OEM parts or equivalents, and documented. For safety-critical components, the repair record should travel with the equipment for its working life.
The competent person who issued the report — or another at the same standard — should verify the repair before the equipment goes back into use. Some defect types require a fresh thorough examination, not just verification. Confirm with your engineer.
File the failed report, the corrective action, the repair record and the verification together. Update your asset register. The next time the same engineer visits, they should be able to see the full story without having to ask.
You have the right to query a report. Discuss it with the competent person; if necessary, escalate to a second opinion. What you cannot do is operate equipment that an engineer has marked as immediately defective while the disagreement is unresolved.
A single failure is information. A pattern of failures is a signal that something deeper needs attention — operator training, maintenance scheduling, equipment selection or supervision. Treat failures as data, not as a black mark.
Get in touch for help with PUWER failures and re-examination.
Not by default. The competent person reports certain serious defects under their own duty; the duty-holder acts on the equipment. RIDDOR may apply separately if an incident has occurred.
A long out-of-service period itself may trigger a fresh thorough examination before return to use. Confirm with your competent person.
Yes, where competent. The repair record needs to be clear, traceable and to manufacturer specification.
No. Each report stands at the time it was issued. The failure shows a change since the last inspection — and the trend data still matters for the future.
Disclaimer: Inspection delivery follows standardised procedures, with outcomes dependent on equipment condition and statutory requirements.
Sign up our newsletter to get helpful updates news and articles.